GemsNY Review 2024
By
This page may contain affiliate links. If you purchase through these links, we may receive a commission. This doesn't affect the opinions or assessments of our editors.
Valentine Day Sale | 20% OFF Sitewide - Exclusive
20% OFF + Free Shipping
Up To 50% OFF Sale Items
Subscribe And Receive $50 Off Your Orders
Up to 30% Off Selected Items
GemsNY has been selling diamonds, gemstones, and jewelry for more than 25 years from Manhattan’s legendary diamond district. Their consumer-facing retail sales are based on their wholesale business, which allows them to sell diamonds, including lab-grown diamonds, at great prices.
Through their physical presence in New York City, they successfully bridge online selling with the ability to visit them and see diamonds in person. In addition, they use their vast experience and deep gemologist expertise to help their customers find the perfect diamonds for their needs.
GemsNY boasts a large selection of high-quality lab-grown diamonds, and that’s why we decided to take a closer look and review GemsNY lab-created diamonds.
In our updated 2023 GemsNY review, we find that GemsNY Diamonds offers good prices on lab-grown diamonds and jewelry, though not as great as the price leaders, Ritani and Clean Origin.
GemsNY is also still somewhat behind our top-rated diamond sellers, James Allen, Clean Origin, Ritani, Grown Brilliance, and Brilliant Earth, who each have a leg up either on buying experience, prices, support, return policies, or environmental impact. Laster in our GemsNY review, we also note that the return period should be slightly longer and less confusing.